Zero-Emission Shipping Needs More Than Zero-Emission Ships
By Wolfgang Lehmacher
Global Supply Chain Advisor & Former Director · World Economic Forum
Mikael Lind
Senior Strategic Research Advisor · RISE Research Institutes of Sweden

When China’s Hubei province announced orders for 89 battery-swapping cargo ships and energy-supply agreements covering 109 barges in September 2026, it put battery-swapping inland shipping on the industrial agenda. The model allows shipowners to buy hulls while leasing batteries, separating assets with different financing and replacement cycles.
An orderbook is not an operating fleet. A zero-emission vessel is not necessarily a dependable transport service. The ship may be ready to sail, yet its battery unavailable, a charging station out of service, energy too expensive, or a supplier unable to perform. The test is not whether the ship can sail, but whether the service can deliver.
Battery leasing makes the distinction between vessel and voyage more important. Separating ownership of the ship from ownership of its power source can reduce the capital tied up in a vessel. It also creates dependencies: the voyage now relies on batteries, infrastructure, operators and contracts working together, seamlessly.
In this case, the decisive question is not who owns the battery. It is whether the cargo still moves when the original setup fails.
Deployment is not proof of readiness
Orders are not an operating fleet, and public reporting does not yet establish realised savings, reliability or performance during disruption.
The Netherlands offers an instructive comparison. Zero Emission Services (ZES) launched a battery-container service with Alphenaar, carrying Heineken beer between Alphen aan den Rijn and Moerdijk. Both cities host strategic inland container terminals operated by CCT Moerdijk and CCT Alphen aan den Rijn (Alpherium), linking the region to the major seaports of Rotterdam and Antwerp. The model combined battery containers, charging infrastructure and pay-per-use arrangements. Heineken and CCT were reported as customers under a ten-year transport agreement.
The service has expanded. In 2025, ZES, ITG and Nedcargo announced a battery-container operation involving Den Bosch Max Groen. As of October 2026, ZES lists five charging stations open, three upcoming in 2026, two ships sailing, two upcoming and 12 vessels awarded conversion subsidies. These figures show that a network exists, not that it is well utilised, profitable or resilient under disruption.
Adoption has fallen short of the original ambition. In July 2026, the Dutch government reported participation substantially below the target of 45 vessels by 2026. It accepted advice against changing the target and said the implications for implementation needed further discussion; the programme was not cancelled.
The lesson is not that battery swapping cannot scale. It is that announced orders, operating services and a commercially sustainable network are different milestones.
Economics depend on the route
Leasing batteries can reduce a vessel’s upfront cost by separating the battery investment from the ship purchase. The cost does not disappear; it is spread over time and may partly shift to the lessor. Lease terms determine how the parties allocate underutilisation, technological obsolescence and declining residual-value risks.
The business case depends on the ship’s business model: distance, energy demand, schedules, charging access, electricity prices and battery utilisation. Predictable traffic can have different economics from irregular journeys across multiple waterways.
A 2025 Nature Energy study by Hee Seung Moon, Won Young Park, Thomas Hendrickson, Amol Phadke and Natalie Popovich from the Energy Analysis and Environmental Impacts Division, Energy Technologies Area, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, CA, USA estimated that electrifying up to 85% of the US domestic vessels under 1,000 gross tonnage become cost-effective by 2035, provided they completed 99% of historical trips and charged from a deeply decarbonised grid. This is a modelled result for battery-electric conversion, not evidence that battery leasing delivers the same economics.
A 2026 optimisation study of battery swapping on Dutch and Belgian inland waterways found that, under its assumptions, market equilibrium might not emerge without public intervention. Replenishing and repositioning swappable batteries are interdependent decisions, trading off battery investment against repositioning costs.
Technical feasibility does not establish commercial viability. Cargo demand, infrastructure, energy supply and financing must work as one system.
The test is what happens when something fails
A vessel may be compatible with a battery container and still be unable to obtain a replacement. The nearest station may be unavailable, another supplier may lack inventory, or a contract may prevent a switch.
Interoperability is not the same as a fallback. Standardised interfaces can make equipment compatible; shared data can help operators exchange information about battery condition, charge and reservations. Neither guarantees that another provider has the batteries, infrastructure, contractual rights or incentive to take over.
Better Place, the electric-vehicle battery-swapping company that entered liquidation in 2013, illustrates the exposure created by dependence on a dedicated energy network. Its failure had multiple causes and does not prove swapping is unworkable. The lesson is that an asset can lose practical value when its supporting service ecosystem disappears.
A commercial-vehicle pilot offers a more recent illustration. In June 2025, Mitsubishi Fuso, Mitsubishi Motors, Ample and Yamato Transport announced a Tokyo project involving more than 150 battery-swappable electric vehicles and 14 planned stations, with Ample operating the infrastructure. Ample filed for Chapter 11 protection in December 2025. On 14 October 2026, the court approved conversion of its case to Chapter 7 liquidation.
That outcome highlights a dependency that vehicle-level economics can overlook: the financial viability of the infrastructure provider. It does not, by itself, establish that the Tokyo pilot failed operationally. The lesson is to plan for provider failure before committing capital.
Due diligence should establish whether another supplier can serve the vessel; whether a battery lease transfers on sale; who bears the cost of a missed swap; how pricing changes if a ship changes corridor; and whether operators or lenders can access essential equipment and data during insolvency or dispute.
Design for continuity
A workable corridor needs three safeguards: credible commercial commitment, operational fallback and enforceable contracts.
- Commercial commitment. Cargo owners must provide credible demand for ship conversion, batteries and infrastructure. Long-term agreements can support investment, but volumes and schedules must be realistic, with remedies if demand falls short.
- Operational fallback. Operators need alternatives when a battery, station, digital system or provider becomes unavailable. These may include reserve batteries, alternative charging, service-recovery procedures or a qualified substitute supplier. Standards can support interoperability; they do not guarantee a fallback.
- Enforceable contracts. Ship, battery, charging and energy agreements must function as one transport service, defining availability, performance, battery degradation, pricing, data access, transfer and termination rights, and step-in arrangements. Responsibility should follow control: each party must answer for what it can influence.
Hybrid propulsion can reduce dependence on charging infrastructure. Aurora Botnia, an eco-friendly RoPax ferry operating between Umeå and Vaasa, combines battery-electric propulsion with liquefied biogas (LBG), allowing operations to continue on fuel when shore electricity is unavailable. Such flexibility provides an additional safeguard for transport continuity.
Sharing planned, estimated and actual ship movements, battery status and charging capacity across involved actors enables forecasting of energy demand and coordination of battery availability, charging and repositioning. This allows stakeholders to anticipate shortages and synchronise transport and energy operations rather than merely reacting to disruptions.
Maritime legal protections require particular care. A contractual waiver cannot eliminate statutory maritime liens or bind third parties in every jurisdiction. Before assuming separate battery ownership protects the vessel, operators and lenders need jurisdiction-specific advice on security interests, vessel arrest, insurance and insolvency.
Six questions for corridor readiness
Before approving a battery-swapping corridor, decision-makers should test six things:
- Demand: Is committed cargo volume sufficient to support the service?
- Economics: Do total costs work under realistic utilisation, electricity-price and financing assumptions?
- Coverage: Are batteries, stations and energy available where and when the schedule requires them?
- Fallback: Can service continue if a battery, station, digital system or provider becomes unavailable?
- Control: Do responsibilities, data access, performance measures and remedies match each party’s control?
- Durability: Can the arrangement survive a ship sale, supplier insolvency, technology change or transfer to another corridor.
A vessel can pass an engineering test and still fail the service test.
The value is continuity
Battery leasing can make zero-emission inland shipping more accessible by separating hull finance from energy-storage finance. It creates value if that separation does not fragment responsibility for the voyage.
Progress should be measured not only in vessels ordered, batteries installed and stations announced, but also in utilisation, service availability, missed swaps, cost per voyage and recovery performance. These measures, not deployment targets, show whether a corridor is commercially ready.
A zero-emission corridor is not ready when its ships can sail on batteries. It is ready when the transport service can withstand disruption and still deliver the cargo.





